WATSON
WYATT, the actuarial consultancy, has vowed to
fight a claim brought against it by Crédit
Lyonnais over the valuation of the French bank's
pension scheme.
The two companies will go to the High Court
on April 25 over allegations that Watson Wyatt
was negligent in valuing Crédit Lyonnais's UK
pension scheme.
The bank has accused
Watson Wyatt of overstating the scheme's assets
and thus allowing Crédit Lyonnais to grant
employees more generous benefits than it would
otherwise have done.
Watson Wyatt is one of three actuarial
companies that dominate the consultancy market,
along with Hewitt and Mercer. As well as
advising on the shape of company pension funds,
the firms also provide investment advice to
trustees.
A Watson Wyatt spokesman said: "I can confirm
that a claim has been brought.
"We are confident that the work we undertook
was entirely appropriate and we are vigorously
contesting the ongoing claim," he added.
The consultancy refused to reveal the value
of the claim but it is believed to be more than
£1 million.
The spokesman said that Watson Wyatt would
attempt to prove that the losses incurred by the
bank were a consequence of management decisions
that were taken without seeking the advice of
the consultancy.
"Watson Wyatt is confident, based on the
independent advice that it has received, that
the court will decide that Watson Wyatt's work
was appropriate and also that the court will
reject the misconceived nature of the claim
generally," the spokesman said.
This is the second time the consultancy has
been implicated in such a case. In late 2003
Syngen, a California-based animal breeding
company, took legal counsel because of advice
that Watson Wyatt gave to the pension fund
trustees at Dalgety, the pet food company that
was broken up in the late 1990s. Syngen was
created from the remains of Dalgety. The case
did not go ahead.
Crédit Lyonnais was not available for comment
last
night.