Jump to main content
Times Online
ARCHIVE CLASSIFIED SHOPPING PROMOTIONS GAMES FAST TIMES MY TIMES WEATHER
Make Times Online
Your Homepage Your Bookmark
NEWSPAPER EDITION
Monday
x
Tuesday
y
Tuesday - Britain
Tuesday - World
Tuesday - Sport
Tuesday - Business
Tuesday - Comment
Tuesday - Times 2
Wednesday
x
Thursday
x
Friday
x
Saturday
x
Sunday Times
x
TIMES ONLINE
Home
Britain
World
Business
Your Money
Sport
Comment
Travel
Entertainment
Law
Crossword
Driving
Property
Women
Health
Jobs
Food and drink
Books
Education
Student
Sunday Times
Site Map
SPECIAL REPORTS
Beyond Eden
Health and Safety
Networked Services
Digital Photography
Child Welfare
Style for Men
Independent Minds
Quebec 2005
Connected Business
Skills and training
Business Travel
The Times Newspaper Edition
The Sunday Times Newspaper Edition
e-paper
The Times and The Sunday Times electronic paper
The Times and The Sunday Times electronic paper

Business

February 22, 2005

Watson Wyatt to fight bank's lawsuit

WATSON WYATT, the actuarial consultancy, has vowed to fight a claim brought against it by Crédit Lyonnais over the valuation of the French bank's pension scheme.

The two companies will go to the High Court on April 25 over allegations that Watson Wyatt was negligent in valuing Crédit Lyonnais's UK pension scheme.

The bank has accused Watson Wyatt of overstating the scheme's assets and thus allowing Crédit Lyonnais to grant employees more generous benefits than it would otherwise have done.

Watson Wyatt is one of three actuarial companies that dominate the consultancy market, along with Hewitt and Mercer. As well as advising on the shape of company pension funds, the firms also provide investment advice to trustees.

A Watson Wyatt spokesman said: "I can confirm that a claim has been brought.

"We are confident that the work we undertook was entirely appropriate and we are vigorously contesting the ongoing claim," he added.

The consultancy refused to reveal the value of the claim but it is believed to be more than £1 million.

The spokesman said that Watson Wyatt would attempt to prove that the losses incurred by the bank were a consequence of management decisions that were taken without seeking the advice of the consultancy.

"Watson Wyatt is confident, based on the independent advice that it has received, that the court will decide that Watson Wyatt's work was appropriate and also that the court will reject the misconceived nature of the claim generally," the spokesman said.

This is the second time the consultancy has been implicated in such a case. In late 2003 Syngen, a California-based animal breeding company, took legal counsel because of advice that Watson Wyatt gave to the pension fund trustees at Dalgety, the pet food company that was broken up in the late 1990s. Syngen was created from the remains of Dalgety. The case did not go ahead.

Crédit Lyonnais was not available for comment last night.

Print this article Send to a friend Back to top of page

  ADVERTISEMENT
BUSINESS SPECIALS
SOUTH WEST ENGLAND
Why doing business here is such a pleasure
HEALTH AND SAFETY
How better health and safety can benefit your business
DIGITAL NETWORKS
How digital networks can help improve your company's performance
CONNECTED BUSINESS
Communications technology revolution
BUSINESS BANKING
Advice and guidance for new businesses
SKILLS AND TRAINING
Indispensable guide to taking on an apprentice

  ADVERTISEMENT
BUSINESS SPECIALS
SME MoT
Give your business an MoT: read our special section for SMEs
STRATEGIES FOR SUCCESS
How small and medium-sized businesses can play to win
BUSINESS TRAVEL
News, reviews and information for the smart traveller


Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times.

Copyright 2005 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers'
standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy .
To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from The Times, visit the Syndication website.